Home / Thespesialnews32

Unraveling The Mystery: Is Sam Really The Father Of Becca's Baby In The Society?

Koby Waters

The Netflix series "The Society" left many viewers with burning questions, and perhaps no mystery sparked more debate than the true parentage of Becca Gelb's baby, Eden. Fans everywhere pondered, discussed, and tried to piece together clues from the show's single season. So, it's almost, you know, a very common question: Is Sam really the father of Becca's baby? The answer, as it turns out, is a bit more complicated than a simple yes or no, yet the show gives us some pretty clear signals.

For anyone who watched the show, the relationship between Becca and Sam was certainly a central part of the story. They shared a deep bond, going way back, and Sam was, in fact, the very first person Becca confided in about her pregnancy. This closeness naturally led many to wonder about their connection to the baby. However, the details of their personal lives reveal a different picture.

You see, Sam Eliot, played by Sean Berdy, is openly gay, and Becca Gelb, portrayed by Gideon Adlon, is straight. The text makes it quite clear: these two have never had a romantic or physical relationship. This crucial piece of information, in a way, immediately takes Sam out of the running as the biological father. Yet, the story unfolds with Sam taking on a very significant role in Eden's life, which is where the real intrigue begins.

Table of Contents

The Truth About Sam's Role

So, to cut right to it, Becca, Sam, and honestly, we as viewers, all know that Sam isn't the biological father of Becca's daughter, Eden. This isn't a secret kept from the audience; it's a known fact within the show's narrative. Sam is gay, Becca is straight, and the two of them have never had sex. This makes him, quite simply, unable to be the biological parent. Sam Eliot has, in fact, agreed to be the baby's father at Becca's request, which is a rather big deal, don't you think? It's all part of a plan to hide the true identity of the father, which remains a puzzle for everyone.

Sam is the adoptive father, but he and Becca decided to tell people that he is the real father, even though he's already out as gay. This arrangement shows just how much Sam cares for Becca and how committed he is to helping her. It’s a pretty significant act of friendship and support, actually. The show really highlights this unusual family dynamic, showing the lengths characters go to for one another in their strange new world. It’s a testament to their bond, more or less.

Why Sam Stepped Up for Becca

The decision for Sam to pose as Eden's father wasn't made lightly. When Sam first learned about Becca's pregnancy, he was the first person she told. This speaks volumes about their close relationship. Sam, being the supportive friend he is, offered to pose as the father. This was primarily to spare Becca from people asking questions and, perhaps, to keep her from being labeled or judged harshly by others in New Ham. She was, after all, pregnant in a very isolated and uncertain situation.

At first, Becca was a bit upset, because she didn't want Sam to commit to something he didn't really want to do. But, he insisted that he wanted a family himself, and she eventually agreed to this arrangement. This reveals a lot about Sam's character; he's someone who values family and connection, even if it's in an unconventional way. The moment that really highlights their unique bond is when Grizz discovers the pregnancy of Sam's best friend, Becca. Grizz gets upset because he thinks Sam is the father, and you might wonder why Sam didn't just say, "Hey man, she got knocked up and I made a promise to her to act as the father of her baby even though I'm really not, so she doesn't get labeled as the town slut." It's a valid point, and it suggests a deeper reason for the secrecy, perhaps Becca's wish to keep the truth from everyone, including Grizz.

Their bond is also shown through their communication. Becca is one of the few people that can fluently sign and speak to Sam in ASL, which just adds another layer to their special connection. This deep understanding between them is a pretty clear reason why Sam would go to such lengths for her, and why she would trust him with such a huge secret. It’s very much a unique friendship, wouldn’t you say?

The Mystery of Eden's Biological Father

While Sam is the acknowledged father, the identity of Eden's biological father remains unknown within the show's narrative, leaving a significant plot hole that fans continue to discuss. "The Society" on Netflix ended with Becca Gelb giving birth to her baby, but she never revealed who the father of Eden is. However, Netflix viewers, like your average person, have found a few hints and developed some compelling theories as to who the father could be. These are all just ideas, of course, but they are based on what we saw.

Is It Campbell?

One of the most prominent theories points to Campbell, Sam's brother. There are a couple of reasons why this idea holds weight. Firstly, Becca really doesn’t want to tell Sam who the father is, and this would certainly explain why. If it were Campbell, and if it was, in fact, non-consensual, that would be a very good reason why Becca didn't tell Sam. Just imagine, she might be worried he'd confront that "creepy greasy-haired rat boy" and get himself killed. This kind of situation would make anyone want to keep a secret, honestly.

Another very telling moment is the scene in the hospital when the baby is born. Kelly tells Sam the baby has his eyes, which seems to upset or disturb Sam. Possibly, he realizes the baby doesn’t have his eyes but his brother's. This subtle reaction from Sam could be a huge clue, suggesting a shared physical trait with Campbell. It's a pretty strong hint, you know, for those paying close attention. Plus, Becca did say to Sam that Eden had his eyes, which, if it was Campbell, would make sense given they are brothers. It’s a bit of a twisted thought, but it fits the narrative.

What About Dewey?

Another theory, which might be a bit of a stretch for some, suggests that Dewey could be the father of Becca's baby. While not as much direct evidence points to him, the show often leaves room for unexpected twists. The dynamic between characters in New Ham is pretty complex, and Dewey's character has his own set of issues. It's an interesting thought, if nothing else, and certainly keeps the speculation going. You know, sometimes the least obvious choice is the correct one.

Other Potential Fathers

Beyond Campbell and Dewey, some viewers reckon it’s either one of the dads, Luke or TW. The show has a way of making you suspect different characters, and these two also fit into the general pool of possible candidates. The lack of a definitive answer means that any male character could theoretically be considered, but the strongest hints seem to lean towards Campbell. It’s all just speculation, of course, but it’s fun to think about, isn’t it?

The reason why many thought it might be someone specific is because when Sam asked who the father is, Becca got so mad and said, "Don't ever ask me that again." Like, she was literally disgusted by the question. This intense reaction suggests the father is someone she deeply resents or fears, which certainly aligns with the Campbell theory, especially if it involved non-consensual circumstances. Her distress in the series photo, where she looks distraught at everything taking place, might also be because she’s responsible for it all in some way, perhaps hiding the true, disturbing nature of Eden’s conception.

Unanswered Questions and Lingering Theories

The camaraderie on Netflix ended with Becca Gelb giving birth to her baby, though she did not reveal who the father of Eden is. This unresolved plot point is a major reason why fans continue to discuss "The Society" even after its cancellation. The show's creators and cast members, like Grace Victoria Cox, who plays Becca, have even admitted they don't know who the father is, which just adds to the mystery. She even mentioned she didn't notice Elle's dog turning up in West Ham at the end until she was told, which just goes to show how many small details were left for us to ponder.

The question of "Is Sam really the father of Becca's baby?" became a shorthand for the larger mysteries of New Ham. Aside from the supernatural questions, the identity of Eden’s father was perhaps the other big question mark. The show, in a way, truly left us hanging. It’s a pretty compelling reason to hope for a continuation, even if it seems unlikely now. Learn more about The Society's mysteries on our site, and link to this page for more character insights.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Sam the biological father of Becca's baby in The Society?
No, Sam Eliot is not the biological father of Becca's baby, Eden. The show makes it clear that Sam is gay and Becca is straight, and they have never had a romantic or sexual relationship. Sam agreed to pretend to be the father at Becca's request to help her and protect her from judgment.

Why did Becca not want to reveal the father of her baby?
Becca was extremely reluctant to reveal the father's identity, becoming very upset when Sam even asked about it. This strong reaction, along with theories pointing to characters like Campbell, suggests the circumstances of Eden's conception might have been traumatic or involve someone dangerous, making Becca want to keep the truth hidden for her safety and perhaps Sam's.

Who are the main theories for the biological father of Becca's baby?
The most popular theory for Eden's biological father is Campbell, Sam's brother, supported by hints like Kelly's comment about the baby having "Sam's eyes" (which could be Campbell's) and Becca's intense secrecy. Other theories include Dewey, Luke, or TW, though less direct evidence points to them.

Augustus Lathrop (1801-1886) | WikiTree FREE Family Tree

Augustus Lathrop (1801-1886) | WikiTree FREE Family Tree

District Index - 1870 Census - Cherokee County Georgia

District Index - 1870 Census - Cherokee County Georgia

Wetzel County, (W)VA 1860 [W-Z] Index

Wetzel County, (W)VA 1860 [W-Z] Index

Detail Author:

  • Name : Koby Waters
  • Username : cordia.stiedemann
  • Email : talia69@yundt.com
  • Birthdate : 2002-09-19
  • Address : 27466 Stoltenberg Green Apt. 892 Lake Derickfurt, MS 83506-6198
  • Phone : 1-206-613-4032
  • Company : Kuphal, Kessler and Beer
  • Job : Textile Knitting Machine Operator
  • Bio : Aut minus velit explicabo incidunt accusamus. Ut perspiciatis aut deleniti omnis similique corporis. Eos soluta voluptas soluta qui exercitationem sit. Sunt autem autem nobis rerum.

Socials

facebook:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/hartmann2019
  • username : hartmann2019
  • bio : Sapiente est a aut ut iste. Iure fugit expedita qui sed rerum facere dicta autem. Nemo voluptas molestiae occaecati odio dolor omnis et.
  • followers : 2395
  • following : 1426

tiktok:

  • url : https://tiktok.com/@amanda_dev
  • username : amanda_dev
  • bio : Aperiam tempore ipsa dolore maxime recusandae impedit tempora.
  • followers : 1084
  • following : 1672

linkedin:

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/hartmann1990
  • username : hartmann1990
  • bio : Est maxime repellendus harum sed. Similique nobis accusantium nesciunt voluptate illo.
  • followers : 3195
  • following : 2720